This Thanksgiving, I Choose to Mourn: On Grief, Gratitude, and the Day of Mourning

Ancestral Wisdom · Ubuntu Philosophy

I will eat this Thanksgiving. I will hold my family close. And I will also mourn—for what was taken from this land, for those no longer at our tables, and for the grief the holiday was never designed to hold.

Every year on Thanksgiving, I do something the holiday was not designed for: I mourn.

I mourn for family members who are no longer at our table—the elders who cooked the dishes we still make, who told the stories we are still telling, whose absence is visible in the particular way an empty chair makes visible. I mourn for the people in this country and around the world who will not eat safely today, who are hungry not by accident but by design, because resources were taken from their communities and redistributed elsewhere.

And I mourn with the Indigenous peoples of this land, for whom Thanksgiving is not a celebration but a wound reopened annually. Their land. Their people. Their ceremony, language, and relationship to this earth — interrupted, suppressed, stolen, and still struggling to be restored.

This is not a way of ruining the holiday. It is a way of honoring what the day actually asks of us, if we are paying attention.

A Day of Mourning — Ubuntu Village reflection on Thanksgiving, grief, and Indigenous truth

The Day of Mourning: What It Is and Why It Matters

In 1970, the United American Indians of New England established the National Day of Mourning, held every year on Thanksgiving at Plymouth Rock. It began with an act of refusal. Wamsutta (Frank B.) James, a Wampanoag leader, had been invited to speak at the state’s official Thanksgiving celebration. When officials previewed his speech and realized he would tell the truth about colonization, they revoked the invitation. He gave the speech anyway to hundreds of people gathered outside. The Day of Mourning was born from the refusal to be erased.

For Native Americans, this day carries what no official holiday can contain: the memory of what was lost. Land. Children taken to boarding schools. Languages stripped away. Ceremonies criminalized. The Trail of Tears. Generations of grief that have not finished moving through Indigenous bodies and communities — grief that shows up as health disparities, shortened life expectancy, and the particular ache of a people still fighting for their own recognition on their own land.

The Day of Mourning asks all of us — not only Indigenous people — to hold that history while we hold our plates. To let it be present. To not pretend that the food we eat arrived here without cost.


The Land We Gather On Has a History

Wherever you celebrate this Thanksgiving, you are on land that was tended, named, and loved by Indigenous people before any of our families arrived. This is not abstract—it is specific. The rivers, forests, and soil have Indigenous names. The agricultural knowledge that fed the first colonists was Indigenous knowledge. The understanding of which plants heal and which plants nourish was cultivated over centuries by people who are still here.

Acknowledging this is not about guilt. Guilt, in my experience, tends to be about the person feeling it — not about the people who were harmed. What I am reaching for is something different: accountability and its companion, repair. Acknowledgment as the beginning of a relationship rather than the end of discomfort.

Ubuntu Village, rooted in East Harlem, works alongside communities in Kenya, in Uganda, and in Nigeria. Everywhere we go, we have learned that the land holds memory. That communities carry the weight of what has been done to them—in their bodies, their health outcomes, and their mental and spiritual lives. That healing requires naming, clearly and without flinching, what actually happened. So this Thanksgiving, I name it. This land was taken. People were killed. Cultures were suppressed. And those cultures, those languages, those relationships with the earth—they were not lesser. They were rich beyond what colonization had the capacity to recognize.


Grief and Gratitude Are Not Opposites

I have learned, through loss, that grief and gratitude do not cancel each other out. They co-exist. The deepest gratitude I know—the kind that brings tears, that makes you stop mid-meal and look around the table as if memorizing the faces there—that gratitude only exists because I know what it is to lose. Gratitude without grief is sentiment. Gratitude that has traveled through grief is something closer to reverence.

Research summarized by Harvard Health suggests that gratitude is linked to better health and greater happiness, and may be associated with longer life. But this is not the gratitude of forced positivity, the kind that tells us to focus only on what we have and ignore what has been taken. That is not gratitude. That is avoidance. Real gratitude requires presence—full presence to beauty and to pain, to what we hold and what we have lost.

This Thanksgiving, I am grateful for my family—for the ones who are here and for the ones whose absence I carry like a second presence alongside me. I am grateful for the work of Ubuntu Village, for the communities that have trusted us, and for every donor who has believed that ancestral wisdom and public health belong in the same conversation. And I am also mourning: for those no longer in our circle, for the children around the world who will not eat safely today, for the Indigenous elders whose languages are leaving with them, for losses I carry privately and with love.

I will not choose between them. Both are true. Both deserve space at the table.

Community gathering in collective mourning and remembrance — National Day of Mourning
The Day of Mourning at Plymouth Rock has been held every Thanksgiving since 1970 — a refusal to be erased.

Grief is carried best in community. Ubuntu Village partners with communities in Kenya, Uganda, and Nigeria who already know how to hold loss together, and we stand beside them.

GIVE TO THE VILLAGE

What Ubuntu Teaches Us About Mourning Together

Ubuntu ngumuntu ngabantu. I am because we are.

In Ubuntu philosophy, no one’s grief is purely private. When one person mourns, the community mourns. When one person heals, healing ripples outward. This is not only spiritual—it is physiological. Co-regulation is real. The nervous system settles in the presence of people who bear witness. Being seen in our grief is part of how we survive it.

Western culture tends to privatize mourning—to see it as something to manage quickly, to get through, to resolve. But ancestral traditions across cultures understand grief differently: as a process that belongs to the whole community, that has its own timing, and that, when honored, becomes the very ground from which gratitude can grow. The Wampanoag knew this. The Zulu know this. African American mourning traditions know this. Grief witnessed in the community does not last forever unchanged—it moves. It transforms. It becomes something that can be carried together, rather than alone.

The Day of Mourning is not an act of despair. It is an act of communal witness. It says: we will not look away. We will hold this together so that no one has to carry it alone. That is a profound act of love.


This Year, I Will Hold Both

This year, as every year, I will eat. I will sit with my family, share food, speak the names of people we love, and give thanks for this day and for each other. I will feel the warmth of it fully and without apology—because joy is not a betrayal of grief. It is its companion.

And I will also pause. I will acknowledge the land we gather on and the people who first called it home. I will say the names of those I am missing. I will sit, however briefly, with the grief that this holiday was not built to hold—and I will hold it anyway, because it is mine to hold.

If you are reading this, I want you to know: you do not have to choose. You are allowed to be grateful and still be grieving. You are allowed to love your family and still be heartbroken about what is happening in the world. You are allowed to enjoy the meal and still say out loud that the story we were told about this day is incomplete.

The most honest form of thankfulness is the kind that has looked at the whole picture—the blessings and the burdens, the beauty and the pain—and chosen, still, to love. That is what Ubuntu teaches. That is what this day, at its deepest, asks of us.

Ubuntu Reflection

Who are you mourning this Thanksgiving? Whose name deserves to be spoken at your table? And what would it mean to make space for both grief and gratitude—not as opposites, but as the two hands of the same love?


Who are you holding in your heart this Thanksgiving — present or absent? Share in the comments. We witness each other here.


References

  1. Silverman, David J. “In 1621, the Wampanoag Tribe Had Its Own Agenda.” The Atlantic, November 27, 2019. theatlantic.com
  2. Harvard Health Publishing. Gratitude Enhances Health, Brings Happiness—and May Even Lengthen Lives. September 11, 2024. health.harvard.edu
  3. United American Indians of New England. National Day of Mourning: Historical Background. uaine.org

Related Reading

Ubuntu Village holds grief and gratitude together. So can you.

Ubuntu Village is a 501(c)(3) rooted in East Harlem with programs in Kenya, Uganda, and Nigeria. We work at the intersection of ancestral wisdom, public health, and community power. Your partnership makes this possible.

Become a Partner →

If this reached you, it may reach someone holding grief and gratitude at the same table. Share it with them.

Michele Mitchell

Michele Mitchell is the Founder, President & CEO of Ubuntu Village Inc., a 501(c)(3) nonprofit with programs in Kenya, Uganda, and Nigeria. A writer, advocate, and community strategist working at the intersection of ancestral wisdom, public health, and community power, Michele leads Ubuntu Village’s work to center communities as the protagonists of their own healing. She writes from the conviction that science and spirit are complementary, that healing is relational, and that community is the medicine. Read more about Michele, or connect with her on LinkedIn.